How to Choose the Best Roof for Your Long Island Home

Clearview Roofing and Construction

To choose the best roof for your Long Island home, consider coastal winds, heavy snowfall, and salt-laden air. Asphalt shingles are cost-effective, and with proper maintenance, they may last as long as metal roofing, which offers superior durability and energy efficiency. Wood shakes work well for a rustic aesthetic but require regular maintenance. 

Besides wind resistance, impact resistance, and UV protection, you also need to weigh the costs of installation, maintenance, and repair. 

In the guide below, Clearview Roofing and Construction shares expert tips on choosing the best roof for your Long Island home.

Call (631) 827-7088 if you have more questions or need help choosing the best roof. Our roofing contractor will answer your questions and offer more guidance.

Key Takeaways

  • Consider Weather Resistance: Choose materials with high wind resistance, impact resistance, and efficient water shedding to withstand Long Island’s coastal winds and heavy snowfall.
  • Evaluate Material Longevity: Opt for durable materials like metal roofing or clay tiles that offer long lifespans and can handle severe weather conditions.
  • Assess Maintenance Needs: Select roofing materials that require manageable maintenance, considering the need for regular debris removal, pressure washing, and inspections.
  • Factor in Aesthetic Appeal: Ensure the roofing material complements your home’s architectural style and neighborhood trends for enhanced curb appeal and market value.
  • Analyze Total Costs: Consider material, installation, warranty, and maintenance costs to make an informed decision that aligns with your budget and long-term investment.

1. Consider roofing material options

When choosing roofing materials for your Long Island home, explore options that offer durability, weather resistance, and energy efficiency. These include options like asphalt shingles, metal roofs, clay tiles and wood shakes. 

Your choice of materials can have a considerable impact on the longevity of our roofs and our home’s aesthetic appeal and overall performance.

Let’s consider four primary roofing materials below.

Asphalt shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing materials due to their cost-effectiveness and ease of installation. They come in various colors to match your roof to your home’s exterior. They’re also relatively simple to replace, making maintenance straightforward.

Metal roofing 

Metal roofing is known for its exceptional durability and energy efficiency. Hence, it’s ideal for those looking to invest in a long-term solution. Installation methods for metal roofing, like standing seam options, could involve interlocking panels, which provide superior weather resistance. Metal roofs also offer various color options, enhancing our homes’ beauty.

Clay tiles

Clay tiles are perfect for those who prefer a Mediterranean or Southwestern aesthetic. These tiles are highly durable with excellent weather resistance. However, their installation methods are more complex and typically require professional expertise. The variety of earthy tones available can add a unique charm to your home.

Wood shakes

Wood shakes are an excellent choice for a rustic, natural look. They provide good insulation and have a distinct aesthetic appeal. However, their installation methods involve more labor, and they require regular maintenance to prevent issues like rot or insect damage. The color variety may be limited to natural wood hues but can be treated to achieve different shades.

2. Consider the climate conditions

Long Island’s unique climate, characterized by coastal winds and high humidity, demands durable and weather-resistant roofing materials. 

High humidity levels can lead to moisture accumulation, which fosters mold growth and wood rot. To prevent these issues, select materials that can effectively repel moisture.

Additionally, the salt-laden air from the Atlantic Ocean accelerates the corrosion of roofing materials. So, you should prioritize roofing options with strong anti-corrosive properties like aluminum roofing

In thermal performance, the fluctuating temperatures between hot summers and cold winters require materials with excellent insulation properties like asphalt shingles. It will maintain energy efficiency, reduce heating and cooling costs, and enhance overall comfort. 

Reflective roofing materials can also mitigate heat absorption during the summer months, contributing to a more stable indoor climate.

Additionally,  the roofing system must be designed to handle snowfall. Accumulated snow adds significant weight and can cause structural strain. You’ll need materials that support this load and facilitate efficient snow shedding to prevent ice dam formation. Therefore, if you’re going for metal roofing, you should choose a thicker metal, like 24-gauge metal roofing.

You may also like: 26-gauge vs 29-guage roofing

3. Consider the roof material’s longevity and durability

When considering longevity and durability for your roofing choices, assess weather resistance and material lifespan

Let’s dive into each aspect below.

Weather resistance

A roof’s weather resistance determines its ability to withstand extreme winds and scorching heat. 

Let’s break down what you should prioritize:

Wind Resistance Ratings: Look for materials that meet or exceed local building codes for wind speeds, often reaching up to 120 mph in Long Island. For example, asphalt shingles classified as Class D for wind resistance resist uplift from winds at 120mph.

Impact Resistance: Our roof should withstand the impact of hail and debris. Materials with a Class 4 impact resistance rating, such as certain shingles and metal roofs, offer the best protection.

UV Protection: Prolonged exposure to UV rays can degrade roofing materials. Ensure your roofing option includes UV-resistant properties to prolong its lifespan and maintain its integrity. For example, GAF’s Timberline® CS Shingles are highly reflective and they also have the highest fire rating.

Material lifespan

When considering roofing materials, evaluate their material warranties and environmental impact. Material warranties provide a safety net, ensuring that you’re covered if the product fails prematurely. Meanwhile, the environmental impact of roofing materials is increasingly important if you aim for more sustainable living.

Here’s a comparison of common roofing materials, their lifespans, and key considerations:


Lifespan (Years)

Key Considerations

Asphalt Shingles


Lower cost, shorter lifespan

Metal Roofing


High durability, recyclable

Wood Shingles


Natural look, higher maintenance

Slate Roofing


Extremely durable, heavy

Clay Tiles


Fire-resistant, environmentally friendly

4. Consider the roofing material’s energy efficiency

Maximizing energy efficiency in your roofing choice directly impacts both your utility bills and environmental footprint. As you explore the options available for Long Island homes, it’s important to consider both solar and insulation efficiency to reduce your energy costs.

When evaluating energy-efficient roofing, consider the following:

Reflective Roofing Materials: These materials are designed to reflect more sunlight and absorb less heat. This keeps our homes cooler and reduces the strain on our air conditioning systems, leading to lower energy bills.

Insulation Efficiency: The right roofing material can significantly improve insulation efficiency. Proper insulation reduces heat transfer, maintaining a consistent indoor temperature. This minimizes the need for heating in the winter and cooling in the summer, contributing to lower energy costs.

Cool Roof Coatings: Applying a reflective coating to an existing roof can enhance its energy efficiency. These coatings are specifically formulated to reflect more UV and infrared sunlight, keeping the roof surface cooler and extending its lifespan.

Solar Panels: Installing solar panels on our roof can generate clean, renewable energy. This reduces reliance on grid electricity, leading to substantial savings over time. Additionally, solar panels can increase a home’s resale value, making it a wise investment.

5. Consider the material’s maintenance requirements

Different roofing materials for Long Island’s homes require varying maintenance requirements, such as cleaning frequency and other seasonal care steps vital for longevity.

Asphalt shingles, for instance, may need annual inspections and occasional moss removal, while metal roofs typically require less frequent upkeep.

Let’s focus on practical schedules and techniques to keep your roofing in top condition year-round.

  • Monthly Debris Removal: Leaves, twigs, and other debris must be removed from the roof surface and gutters monthly to prevent water pooling and potential structural damage.
  • Biannual Pressure Washing: A gentle pressure wash can help eliminate moss, algae, and dirt. However, you should be cautious with pressure settings to avoid shingle damage.
  • Quarterly Inspections: A visual inspection every three months helps identify and rectify minor issues before they escalate. Professionals look for signs of mold, mildew, or broken shingles.
  • Annual Professional Cleaning: Hiring a local roofing contractor annually ensures a thorough cleanup and allows for a professional assessment of roof health, addressing any hidden problems.
  • Gutter maintenance in Spring and Fall. You must clear out leaves, twigs, and other obstructions from gutters and downspouts to ensure proper water flow. Inspecting for loose or damaged shingles is also essential to prevent leaks.

Additionally, snow and ice accumulation can lead to ice dams, which can cause significant damage. We must ensure proper attic insulation and ventilation to mitigate this risk. Finally, removing snow from the roof can prevent excessive load and potential collapse.

6. Consider the costs and warranties

Estimate the cost of various roofing materials to balance durability, aesthetics, and budget. 

When evaluating the financial aspect of your roof, consider installation costs, material longevity, and warranty terms.

Let’s break down the primary elements that influence overall roofing expenses:

Material Costs: Different materials come with varying price tags. Asphalt shingles are the most economical, while slate tiles and metal roofs can be more expensive. 

Installation Costs: Labor is a substantial part of roofing expenses. Complex roof designs or higher-end materials typically require skilled labor, which increases installation costs. 

Warranty Terms: A warranty saves you money in the long run. Most asphalt shingles come with a 15-30-year warranty, while metal roofs could offer up to 30 years or more warranties. The warranty’s length and coverage can reflect the material’s quality and expected lifespan.

Maintenance and Repair Costs: Long-term expenses include maintenance and potential repairs. Asphalt shingles might need periodic replacement and repair, adding to the lifetime cost. While pricier upfront, metal roofs often require less maintenance, providing savings over time.

Considering these factors will help you make an informed decision and ensure you get the best value for your roof investment.

Call Clearview Roofing and Construction at (631) 827-7088 to determine an accurate roof installation cost.

7. Consider the roof’s aesthetic appeal

A roof’s aesthetic appeal influences a home’s overall curb appeal and market value, making it important to choose a material and design that harmonizes with the architectural style of your Long Island home. 

Consider color coordination and neighborhood trends to guarantee your roof complements your home’s exterior and surroundings.

The roof color should align with the home’s siding, trim, and exterior elements. For instance, if your home has a classic Colonial design, a slate gray or black shingle might be ideal, providing a timeless look. On the other hand, a Mediterranean-style home could benefit from terra-cotta tiles to enhance its warm, rustic charm. A color wheel can help you identify complementary and analogous colors, ensuring a cohesive aesthetic.

Observe neighborhood trends. Your roof should neither clash with nor mimic your neighbors’ roofs too closely. Instead, it should strike a balance that respects the local architectural vernacular while allowing some individuality. For instance, if asphalt shingles dominate your neighborhood, opting for a high-quality architectural shingle with a unique pattern could set your home apart without appearing out of place.

Material choice also plays an important role. While asphalt shingles are versatile and widely accepted, metal roofs can offer a modern, sleek appearance, and wood shakes provide a natural, rustic look. Each material comes with its own color options and styles, so choosing one that aligns with our aesthetic goals and your home’s structural requirements is vital.

Call (631) 827-7088. Clearview Roofing and Construction will help you choose the best roof for your Long Island home’s needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find a reputable roofing contractor in Long Island?

To find a reputable roofing contractor in Long Island, check contractor reviews online. Look for consistent positive feedback and high ratings. Verify their insurance coverage to ensure they’re protected against liabilities. Don’t forget to ask for references and check their portfolio of previous work. A reliable contractor will provide a detailed estimate and timeline, demonstrating their expertise and professionalism.

What are the signs that I need a roof replacement?

Signs you need roof replacement include leaks, shingle deterioration, and water stains on ceilings or walls. Shingles that are cracked, curling, or missing granules indicate significant wear. Additionally, if our roof is over 20 years old, it’s time to contemplate replacement to guarantee structural integrity and prevent costly damages.

Can I install a new roof over an existing one?

Yes, you can install a new roof over an existing one, known as roof layering or overlay. However, call Clearview Roofing and Construction to assess the current roof’s condition. If the existing shingles are in good shape and there’s no significant water damage or structural issues, roof overlay can be cost-effective. Consult Clearview Roofing and Construction to confirm compliance with local building codes and standards.

How long does the roof installation process typically take?

The project duration ranges from a few days to a week. Factors influencing this include the roof’s size, complexity, weather conditions, and the crew’s efficiency.

Are there any local regulations or permits required for roof installation?

Long Island has specific regulations requiring permits before starting any roofing project. Consult the local building department to guarantee compliance with these codes. Also, zoning laws might dictate the type and color of roofing materials we can use. Ignoring these regulations can lead to fines or mandatory modifications.

Get Started Today

Get a quote for your new roof by filling out the form below. A technician will follow up with you in 1-2 business days.