Embarking on a roofing project often comes with a cloud of budget uncertainty. With many factors influencing costs, homeowners can quickly feel overwhelmed when pinpointing their expenses. Yet planning your budget can significantly alleviate these concerns, providing clarity and peace of mind as you navigate the roofing landscape. 

The cost of a new roof in Long Island includes the roofing materials, labor, and additional features like siding, among other things. On average, roofing materials cost $7 to $25 per square foot, and roofing labor costs roughly $500 per square foot.  

As you can calculate the total cost, remember that these costs vary based on the material’s grade, the existing roof’s condition, and more, depending on your circumstances. 

If you’d like to speak to someone who will understand your needs and recommend the right solution, call us! We have helped over 400 satisfied homeowners restore their properties in Long Island. You can also request a free estimate.

Read on to discover the costs of installing a new roof in Long Island in 2023.

tile roofing system

How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Long Island, NY, 2023?

On average, homeowners in Long Island can expect to pay roughly $500 per square foot in labor costs for a new roof in 2023. One ”square” corresponds to 100 square feet of roofing material.  So, if your home requires 2,000 square feet of roofing material, you should budget anywhere from $10,000 at a rate of $500 per square. This rate covers a broad spectrum of roof types, from standard options to high-end installations. 

The cost of a new roof in Long Island is influenced by various factors, making it challenging to provide a one-size-fits-all price. The spectrum of prices is vast, primarily influenced by the roof’s size, materials, labor involved, and unique features. 

Here’s a more detailed breakdown:

Material Grade

  • Standard Grade: This category is often chosen for its affordability. Typically lasting 10-15 years, materials in this grade are priced between $2 to $6 per square foot. It’s economical but may require more frequent maintenance or earlier replacement.
  • Premium Grade: A step above the standard, the premium grade offers better protection against the elements and has an extended lifespan of up to 20 years. It balances cost and durability, costing between $7 to $12 per square foot.
  • Ultra-Premium Grade: For those prioritizing longevity and premium quality, ultra-premium materials are the way to go. These materials, priced between $160 to $200 per square foot, boast 25 years or longer lifespans. While they come with a heftier price tag, the investment often pays off in reduced maintenance and longer intervals before replacement.

Labor Costs

The labor for roof installation is a substantial portion of the overall expenditure. In Long Island, this typically ranges from $200 to $500 per square foot installed. The final figure can fluctuate based on the complexity of the roof’s design, the ease of access, and other localized challenges. For instance, intricate designs with multiple valleys and ridges or homes that are more than a single story often incur higher labor costs due to increased complexity and safety measures.

Existing Roof’s Condition

Another critical factor is the state of the current roof. Homes, especially those constructed in the 80s in Long Island, may have outdated sheathing. Current building codes in many areas require ½” sheathing. If your home currently has ⅜” sheathing, an upgrade will be necessary, potentially pushing the price.

The Cost of Different Roofing Materials in Long Island, NY

Roofing Material


Cost (per sq. ft.)


Lightweight, coated for protection

$7.00 – $14.00

Architectural Shingles (Asphalt)

A modern, thicker variant of the 3-tab

$500 – $800

Cedar Shingles

Durable and visually pleasing

$7.00 – $12.00

Clay Shingles

Heated clay, e.g., Spanish tiles

$20 – $25

Concrete Tiles

Lightweight design option

$19 – $23

Cypress Shakes

Durable, rot-resistant

$8.00 – $15.00

Designer Shingles (Asphalt)

Unique designs

$600 – $900

Stone Coated Steel

Very durable

$7 – $15


Solid, fire-resistant

$8.00 – $15.00

Natural Slate 

Made from real stone

$18.00 – $25.00

Synthetic Slate

Made from recycled materials

$11.00 – $17.00


Lightweight and affordable

$7.00 – $10.00


Available in EPDM, TPO, PVC

$8.00 – $10.00


Lifespan of 50-60 years

$10.00 – $20.00

Wood Shingles

Made from wood blocks 

$12 – $20

Additional Features that May Affect the Price of Your New Roof

When evaluating the cost of a new roof in Long Island, NY, the basic material and labor charges are just the starting point. Several additional features can influence the total expense of your roofing project. With our years of experience in the industry, Clearview Roofing and Construction understands the nuances that can impact roofing costs. Let’s delve into some of these features that homeowners should consider:

gable roof

Roof Complexity

The design of your roof – whether it’s a simple gable or a more intricate mansard – can influence labor costs. A roof with multiple valleys, dormers, or skylights requires additional craftsmanship and materials. These intricate designs can increase the installation complexity, subsequently influencing the price.

Removal of Old Roofing

The cost of removing and disposing of your old roofing material can vary, especially if you have multiple layers of shingles or tiles. The more layers there are, the more labor and waste management fees you might incur.

Underlayment Type

The underlayment is a barrier between the roofing material and the deck, protecting water and ice. There are different types of underlayments, and their costs can vary. Investing in a high-quality underlayment may increase the initial costs but can extend the lifespan and efficiency of your roof.

Flashing and Roof Accessories

Flashings are crucial components that help waterproof a roof’s intersections, valleys, and penetrations. Depending on the material (copper, aluminum, steel) and the amount needed, this can alter the total expenditure. Additionally, other roof accessories like gutters, ridge vents, and soffits, while enhancing the functionality and aesthetics of your roof, can also impact the budget.

Special Treatments

Special treatments or coatings may be recommended for homes with specific environmental challenges, like high humidity or proximity to saltwater. These treatments can increase the roof’s resistance to moss, algae, and salt-air corrosion, ensuring longevity. While these treatments might increase initial costs, they can save homeowners on long-term maintenance and repairs.

Unexpected Repairs

During roofing, unforeseen issues like rotting wood, damaged insulation, or pest infestations might surface. Allocating a contingency budget for unexpected repairs ensures you’re prepared for surprises.

Warranty Options

Roofing materials typically come with manufacturer warranties. However, extended or enhanced warranties might be available at an additional cost. These offer peace of mind to homeowners, ensuring that any defects or issues arising from the material or installation are covered.

Local Building Codes and Permits

In certain regions, including parts of Long Island, local building codes may require specific roofing materials or techniques, especially in areas prone to extreme weather or seismic activity. Acquiring permits and adhering to these codes might add to the cost of the roofing project.

Insurance Premiums

Updating your roof, especially with durable and high-quality materials, can often decrease homeowner’s insurance premiums. However, some insurance companies might require an inspection before offering a discount. Budgeting for the possible inspection fee and communicating with your insurance provider about potential savings is crucial.

Temporary Accommodation

For extensive roofing projects or if certain complications arise, homeowners might find it more convenient or necessary to seek temporary accommodation. This ensures safety and can be more comfortable than living in a construction zone.

Choosing a New Roof: Additional Considerations


  • ROI (Return on Investment): When investing in a new roof, homeowners should consider the potential return. A high-quality roof installation can significantly increase the home’s resale value. Plus, energy-efficient materials can result in monthly savings on energy bills.
  • Aesthetic Value: Beyond functionality, a new roof can significantly improve the aesthetic value of a home. Consider the architectural style of your home and the desired look and feel when choosing materials and colors.
  • Maintenance: Depending on the roofing material chosen, maintenance requirements can vary. Some materials require regular inspections and maintenance, while others are virtually maintenance-free. Understand the maintenance commitment of the chosen material before installation.
  • Roofing Contractor’s Experience: Experience counts! Ensure that the contractor you choose has ample experience installing the type of roof you’re interested in. You need a contractor who will install your roof right the first time, like Clearview Roofing and Construction. Over 60 years of experience, 400+ positive reviews, and multiple Angie’s List Super Service awards cement our status as Long Island’s top roofing company. For expert advice, competitive pricing, and unmatched quality, contact us. 
  • Duration: Ask how long the installation will take so that you can prepare for any inconveniences. The installation might take several days or even weeks, depending on the size and complexity of the roof and weather conditions.
  • Safety Precautions: Ensure that the contractor takes safety seriously. They should have proper safety equipment, training, and protocols in place. This not only ensures their safety but can also prevent potential liabilities for homeowners.

When getting roof quotes, be cautious of offers below $500 per square, as the contractor might lack the necessary insurance and quality assurance. Insufficient coverage often correlates with subpar workmanship and disregard for property care.

What Time of Year is Cheapest to Replace a Roof?

Traditionally, the roofing industry experiences peaks and valleys in terms of demand. In areas like Long Island, NY, late spring to early fall is the peak roofing season due to favorable weather conditions. Therefore, prices might be slightly higher during this period due to increased demand. 

On the other hand, late fall to early winter tends to be a slower period for roofing projects. You may get discounts or promotions as contractors try to maintain steady business during these times. However, while you might save on costs, weather conditions could be less predictable, potentially leading to project delays.

Money-Saving Tips When Getting a New Roof

  • Consider Off-Peak Seasons: Roofing during the off-peak seasons might offer cost benefits. However, be prepared for potential weather-related delays.
  • Recycle Old Materials: Instead of paying for disposal, see if you can recycle your old roofing materials. Companies might even offer a discount for the recyclable material.
  • Invest in Quality: While it might be tempting to go for the cheapest material, investing in quality can save money in the long run by reducing repair and replacement costs.
  • Inquire About Discounts: It doesn’t hurt to ask!
  • Opt for Energy-Efficient Materials: Consider incorporating skylights into your new roof to reduce the need for artificial lighting during the day. But while skylights can offer efficient lighting and save energy costs, their effectiveness depends on their specifications, placement, and installation. Clearview Roofing and Construction offers a no-leak skylight guarantee to enhance your confidence in this upgrade so that you never have to worry about potential water damage.
  • Plan Ahead: Unexpected costs can arise from delays or last-minute changes. You can avoid additional costs by planning and being clear about what you want.

Work with a Roofer You Can Trust at a Fair Price!

Prospective costs can be a significant concern when considering a new roof installation in Long Island. But while cost is essential, the value lies in the craftsmanship and reliability of the roofer you choose.  Clearview Roofing and Construction brings the tangible experience to ensure your roofing job is executed professionally and at a fair price. Our expansive operations, now spread across four local offices, are strategically positioned to ensure minimal travel costs, making our pricing even more competitive.

Our expertise isn’t limited to just new installations. Whether you have a flat or pitched roof, need urgent repairs, or are looking to elevate your home with slate roofs, diagnose those elusive leaks, or enhance with skylights and gutters, we have the skills and tools necessary. Our journey spans over six decades, and the testament to our commitment is evident in 400+ positive reviews. When making that crucial decision for your home, remember it’s not just about the roof but the hands that craft it. With Clearview Roofing and Construction, you choose more than a service; you select trust, quality, and unmatched expertise.

Cedar Roof Installation

Get Started Today

Get a quote for your new roof by filling out the form below. A technician will follow up with you in 1-2 business days.