By Chris Feniello
Your insurance company sent a letter saying replace your roof or lose your coverage. We inspected the roof in person and found it still has life left. Now what?
This is what a conflicting roof report is for. It is the document you submit to your carrier to get a second look at the decision. Below is a walkthrough of what one actually contains, using a sample report with the homeowner’s details removed.
If you are holding one of these letters yourself, start with our main page on the subject: Insurance Company Says Replace Your Roof or Lose Coverage?
What the report is — and what it is not
A conflicting roof report is not a letter that says “the roof looks fine.” Carriers ignore those.
It is a documented, photo-backed professional assessment of the roof’s actual condition, written by a roofer who stood on the roof. Its job is to give the carrier something it did not have when it made the original decision: evidence from an in-person inspection.
It is also not a guarantee. No roofer can promise a carrier will reverse its decision. What the report does is put a real inspection on the record, so the carrier’s file no longer contains only its own remote assessment.
The sample report, section by section
The example below is based on a real report we prepared for a homeowner in Nassau County. Names, addresses, and policy details have been removed. The findings are the homeowner’s actual findings.
1. Summary and conclusion, up front
The report opens with the conclusion, not the details. A carrier reviewer should know in the first paragraph what the report says:
The roof at the subject property was inspected in person on [date]. In our professional opinion, the roof is in serviceable condition with an estimated remaining useful life of [X] years. The roof does not require full replacement at this time.
No hedging, no sales language. The conclusion goes first because that is how the rest of the report gets read.
2. Property and roof identification
This section records the facts of the roof itself:
- Roof type and material (in this case, architectural asphalt shingles)
- Approximate age of the roof and, where known, the installation history
- Number of layers, roof pitch, and general layout
- Date of inspection and weather conditions at the time
This matters because carriers often decide from a file that has the roof’s age wrong or incomplete. Getting the basic facts on the record correct is the first step.
3. Inspection method
A short section stating plainly how the inspection was done: the roofer walked the roof, examined the shingles, flashing, valleys, penetrations, and ventilation, and photographed conditions as found. Nothing fancy. The point is that this was an in-person inspection, not a review of satellite imagery.
4. Condition findings, with photographs
This is the heart of the report. Each finding is paired with a dated photograph taken during the inspection. In the sample report, the photos showed:
- Shingle condition: Shingles lying flat with no widespread curling, cupping, or missing tabs. Minor granule wear consistent with the roof’s age, but no exposed mat or bald patches.
- Flashing: Step flashing and counter flashing intact at walls and chimneys, with no visible separation or failed sealant.
- Valleys: Valleys clear of debris and showing no signs of deterioration or leaking.
- Penetrations: Vent pipes, skylight curbs, and exhaust vents flashed and sealed, with no cracked boots or open gaps.
- Ventilation: Intake and exhaust ventilation present and unobstructed.
- Prior repairs: One area of prior repair noted, documented, and holding — recorded honestly rather than hidden.
Every photo is labeled with what it shows and where on the roof it was taken. A carrier reviewer can follow the photos around the roof the same way the inspector did.
5. Remaining life expectancy
Based on the inspection, the report gives a professional estimate of how much useful life the roof has left — in this case, a range of years, not a single number, because no honest roofer can pin a roof’s remaining life to an exact year.
This is the number the carrier cares about most. It is also the number that has to be believable, which is why it is backed by the photos and findings above it rather than stated on its own.
6. Maintenance and repair notes
Where applicable, the report notes maintenance history and any repairs completed, so the carrier can see the roof has been cared for. In the sample report, this included routine gutter cleaning and the one prior repair noted above.
If the roof needs targeted repairs before it can be documented as sound, the report says so plainly, and lists exactly what. A report that hides needed repairs is worthless — the carrier will find them, and then it will not believe anything else in the document.
7. Contractor identification
The report closes with Clearview’s identification: company name, Long Island offices, and contact information, so the carrier knows the assessment comes from an established roofing contractor, not from the homeowner alone.
How a carrier reads it
When your carrier or agent receives the report, here is what actually happens in most cases:
- The file is reopened and the new documentation is added to it.
- A reviewer — or in some cases a third-party inspector the carrier hires — compares the report against the original basis for the replacement demand.
- If the original demand was based on age or aerial imagery rather than an actual failure, the in-person report carries real weight, because it answers the exact question the carrier’s file could not: what is the roof’s actual condition?
- The carrier issues a revised decision, or it does not. Either way, you get the answer in writing.
The honest note from our main page applies here too: we cannot guarantee any carrier’s decision. What we can guarantee is that your submission will be based on a real inspection, real photographs, and a professional assessment we stand behind.
What to do if you are holding a letter
Do not ignore the letter, and do not sign a replacement contract under deadline pressure before anyone has looked at your roof. The first step is an in-person inspection.
Call Clearview Roofing & Construction at 631-262-7663. Tell us you received an insurance roof replacement demand or non-renewal notice, and share the deadline if you have it. We will get on your roof, give you a straight answer, and if the roof has life left, prepare a report like the one above.
Related reading:
- Insurance Company Says Replace Your Roof or Lose Coverage?
- Roof Inspection — what a Clearview inspection covers
- Roof Replacement — when replacement genuinely is the right call
- Roof Repair — targeted repairs that can come first
About the Author
Chris Feniello is the Managing Partner of Clearview Roofing & Construction, a Long Island roofing company serving Suffolk and Nassau counties since 1961. He leads the company’s roofing, insurance-claims, and construction work across its five Long Island offices.
Clearview Roofing & Construction serves Suffolk and Nassau counties, with offices in Northport, Babylon, and Huntington, and Port Washington and Rockville Centre. Headquarters: 171 Main Street, Port Washington, NY 11050.